Feature · Feature · Media

Measured, repeatedly

Fifteen years of research into how British media portrays Black people

Measured, repeatedly

Ten studies, fifteen years, one pattern. British newsrooms and broadcasters have been measuring their own coverage of Black people since at least 2008 — and the findings barely move. What follows is the evidence, laid out plainly, and what it adds up to.

There is a particular kind of argument that gets had on British television every few years. Someone says the media portrays Black people unfairly. Someone else says that is a feeling, not a fact. The conversation ends where it started.

It does not have to. The measurement has been done, repeatedly, by universities, by the broadcasting regulator, by newsroom bodies and by the BBC itself. The studies use different methods and different decades. They arrive at strikingly similar places.

Two thirds of news items about Black boys and young men concerned crime. Stories about achievement or positive community roles accounted for 3.8%.

What the coverage is about

Cardiff University’s REACH Media Monitoring Project analysed 499 UK print, television and radio news items featuring Black boys and young men, alongside qualitative analysis of crime reporting and interviews with journalists. It found that 66.9% of stories concerned crime, while achievement and positive community roles accounted for 3.8%. Coverage repeatedly associated Black boys and young men with violent crime, knives, gangs and murder. Moore, Jewell & Cushion, 2011

The researchers were careful about what they were claiming. They did not find a single stereotype repeated uniformly in every item. They found something subtler and harder to argue with: a strongly crime-centred pattern of representation, produced not by any one decision but by thousands of individually defensible ones.

Three years earlier, the Runnymede Trust had examined the role of race and ethnicity of victims and perpetrators in press reporting of violent crime. Its conclusion described a loop: popular understandings of race and crime influence media reporting, and that reporting in turn helps reproduce those understandings. Runnymede Trust, 2008

The pattern extends beyond news. The Sir Lenny Henry Centre analysed UK factual and documentary output across major broadcasters and found crime was a leading theme in programmes representing Black people — for Channel 5, the largest single category at 22%. Interviewees described limited control over commissioning, development and storytelling. Its conclusion was that representation has to be assessed through subject matter and decision-making power, not only through who appears on screen. Sir Lenny Henry Centre, 2022

What audiences say about it

Ofcom’s research on the BBC found 60% of Black audiences rated the broadcaster positively for representation — but only 45% felt positively about how Black people were portrayed. Ofcom, 2020

That fifteen-point gap is the most useful number in this entire body of research. It separates two things that are routinely conflated. Being on screen is not the same as being depicted in a way you recognise. Visibility is countable; portrayal is not, which is precisely why organisations prefer to report the first.

Qualitative work for Ofcom by Kantar filled in what the gap contains. Participants described minority ethnic appearances and roles as sometimes tokenistic, superficial, peripheral or limited. They raised concerns about outdated stereotypes. Some Black presenters were perceived as constrained in how they could appear or speak. What participants wanted was not more airtime in the abstract — it was richer, more ordinary, more varied portrayals. Ofcom / Kantar, 2018

More ordinary. Not more flattering, not more prominent — more ordinary. The request is to be depicted at the same resolution as everybody else.

Who is in the room

The Reuters Institute at Oxford surveyed UK journalists and compared the results with census data. 90% of surveyed journalists were White; 1.3% were Black, against approximately 4% of the population recorded as Black in the 2021–22 censuses. Ethnic-minority journalists were less likely to hold management roles. Reuters Institute, 2023

Ofcom’s workforce data found the same shape in broadcasting: Black people held 1% of senior television management positions, while making up 3% of the national working population. Ofcom, 2020

The Ethical Journalism Network went further, conducting 27 in-depth interviews with Black journalists and stakeholders across national print, online and broadcast newsrooms. Interviewees reported exclusionary processes, racial stereotyping, microaggressions, limited senior representation, pressure to become the default voice on race, and weak institutional responses to racism. The report found race coverage often lacked nuance or sustained discussion of causes and solutions — and concluded that newsroom power structures affected both the experience of Black journalists and the framing of the output itself. Ethical Journalism Network, 2023

The absence, and the language

Analysis of UK national and local press commissioned within the European Monitoring Centre on Racism and Xenophobia programme found ethnic-minority people received limited routine coverage and were marginal as speakers and as ordinary actors in news. When minority issues were prominent, stories frequently involved immigration, terrorism or crime. Firmstone et al., 2009

That is a finding about absence, which is harder to notice than a bad headline. Being missing from ordinary coverage — the consumer story, the weather piece, the vox pop — while being highly present around a handful of contentious agendas produces a distorted picture without a single false sentence being published.

Most recently, the Runnymede Trust analysed parliamentary and media debate between 2010 and 2024 and identified recurring language constructing migrants and racially minoritised communities as threats, through narratives of control, surveillance, disorder and pressure on public resources. Its conclusion was that these debates made racialised exclusion appear ordinary or justified. Runnymede Trust, 2025

What it adds up to

Read individually, each of these reports is arguable. Sample sizes can be questioned. Methods differ. Any single finding can be explained away by news values, by what happened that year, by what audiences click on.

Read together, they describe a system with consistent properties across fifteen years, multiple media, and every methodology anyone has thought to apply. Crime dominates the subject matter. Ordinary life is largely absent. Audiences notice the difference between being visible and being recognised. And the people deciding what gets commissioned, framed and published are, at senior level, drawn from a very narrow slice of the country.

The most striking thing about this evidence base is not any individual number. It is that the numbers were gathered, published, and largely acted upon as a communications problem rather than an editorial one.

None of this requires anyone to have acted in bad faith, which is what makes it durable. A newsroom with 1.3% Black journalists and almost none in management will produce coverage shaped by the instincts of the people in the room. Those instincts will feel like news judgement, because to them they are.

The measurement has been done. Repeatedly, carefully, and by the institutions themselves. What has not happened is the part where the measurement changes the thing being measured.

Sources: Moore, Jewell & Cushion, Media Representations of Black Young Men and Boys (Cardiff University / REACH, 2011) · Runnymede Trust, A Tale of Two Englands (2008) and A Hostile Environment (2025) · Ofcom, Representation and Portrayal on the BBC (2020) and UK broadcasting workforce data (2020) · Ofcom / Kantar qualitative research (2018) · Ethical Journalism Network, Structural Racism in UK Newsrooms (2023) · Reuters Institute, The Personal Characteristics and Diversity of UK Journalists (2023) · Firmstone et al., Representation of Minorities in the Media: UK (2009) · Sir Lenny Henry Centre, Black in Fact: Beyond the White Gaze (2022).

Write for the Digest

Comment and first-person pieces are open for pitches — 800 to 1,500 words. Send a pitch, or read the rest of the Digest.